Photo printing.

[brucem]

I have recently changed my printer from Epson to a Brother DCP-J1050DW.  I have a nearly full packet of EPSON Premium Glossy Photo Paper.  I have tried it in the Brother machine.  It gives the paper options of: Plain paper, Inkjet paper, Brother Glossy photo paper (BP71 GP), Matte photo paper (BP60 matte), Other photo paper.  I have tried telling the machine that I am using BP71 GP, and Other photo paper in separate tries.  Neither produces even vaguely useful prints.  Is there any option than
buying new paper?